By Dr. Ken Broda Bahm: Watching a mock jury deliberate about damages can give you the idea that when it comes to numbers, jurors can be a little random. For example, a jury might see a big difference between $500,000 and $1 million in one moment, and then act as though there is little to […]
Add Numeracy to Your Jury Read More »
By Dr. Ken Broda Bahm: It is well-known at this point that civil trials are giving way to settlements. One of the factors that make settlement the more attractive alternative is that settlement is an uncertainty-reduction strategy: The known amount of cash in or out of pocket reduces the risk of the unknown for both
Consider How Jurors Arrive at Damages Numbers: In Stages and With Difficulty Read More »
By Dr. Ken Broda Bahm: Flip a coin, roll the dice, pick a number, throw a dart — there is no shortage of metaphors for the perceived randomness of juries. That belief that “anything can happen,” is applied to some extent to the whole jury model, but nowhere more so than on the topic of
Make Your Damages Numbers Meaningful Read More »
By Dr. Ken Broda Bahm: There is one topic that nearly always comes up in mock trial discussions: the McDonald’s hot coffee case. It can be a circumstance as distinct as a patent case, and at least one juror will somehow find a connection. When the discussion turns to damages — and especially punitive damages
Expect Jurors to Want to Follow the Money Read More »
By Dr. Ken Broda Bahm: As a response to the perception of escalating jury awards in medical cases, a number of states have turned to legislative caps on noneconomic damages or overall damages. At last count, that preference for legislative limits on verdict amounts applies to all but 15 states (Alabama, Arizona, Arkansas, Connecticut, Delaware,
Medical Defendants: Don’t Put All Your Faith in Caps Read More »
By Dr. Ken Broda Bahm: (Marie Colvin, Journalist, 1956-2012) Legal cases are about loss: asserting, proving, disputing, and defending against loss. Those who study and practice civil litigation have a strong interest in knowing how people comprehend and give meaning to loss, because that is what determines their reaction to your case. And current events provide a
By Dr. Ken Broda Bahm – Aristotle, the original philosopher of communication, wrote in The Nicomachean Ethics about “the Golden Mean, ” or the idea that virtue is often a happy medium between two vices (for example, courage is the virtue wedged between the vices of recklessness on the one hand, and cowardice on the other). More
Aim Your Damages, And Your Case, at “The Golden Mean” Read More »
By Dr. Ken Broda Bahm – “Well…let me just throw a number out to get us rolling: Five million dollars!” (Recent mock juror quote) Juror damage awards can seem erratic and inexplicable, not only to the public, but to experienced litigators as well. Particularly when jurors are valuing something other than a concrete expense by assessing non-economic
Get the Gist of How Jurors Decide Damage Numbers Read More »