Your Trial Message

Voir Dire

Think Carefully About Disparate Impact in Voir Dire

By Dr. Ken Broda Bahm: Thanks to Batson and associated cases, we now have an uneasy working rule on voir dire in U.S. courtrooms: In exercising peremptory strikes, you can pick and choose on any basis…other than discriminatory ones. Basing strikes on race, ethnicity, gender, nationality and some other demographic categories is not allowed. That prohibition, however, is widely considered […]

Think Carefully About Disparate Impact in Voir Dire Read More »

Voir Dire: Account for Both Presumptions and Expectations

By Dr. Ken Broda Bahm: A newly-published study about the effects of voir dire in capital cases suggests that social scientists and the courts may need to reconsider a long-held tenet. For at least the past 35 years, the belief has been that jurors exposed to the process of jury selection in capital cases, known as

Voir Dire: Account for Both Presumptions and Expectations Read More »

The Oil and Gas Juror: Look for Both Familiarity and Contempt

By Dr. Ken Broda Bahm: You’ve heard the expression: “Familiarity breeds contempt.” Maybe there is a relationship between the two, but in the courtroom, and in the practical task of assessing experience and attitudes during voir dire, they are two different things. First, there is the question of how much knowledge and experience jurors will

The Oil and Gas Juror: Look for Both Familiarity and Contempt Read More »

Consider the Complacent: Belief in a Favorable Future (BFF) Isn’t Always Your Friend

By Dr. Ken Broda Bahm: What a potential juror thinks is, of course, critical to the decision to keep or to strike. But that notion of “what she thinks” means, not just her opinions, but also the broader attitudes and dispositions that lie beneath the surface. That’s why the gold standard in voir dire is to

Consider the Complacent: Belief in a Favorable Future (BFF) Isn’t Always Your Friend Read More »

Use Community Attitude Surveys as an Uncertainty Reduction Strategy

By Dr. Ken Broda Bahm: Many have observed the continued decline of the civil jury trial. One reason trial by jury is falling out of favor in civil disputes is that parties and counsel treat it like the ultimate mystery, and this uncertainty makes the alternate ways to resolve the dispute look a lot safer.

Use Community Attitude Surveys as an Uncertainty Reduction Strategy Read More »

Know the Principles: A Review of the “Jury Selection Handbook”

By Dr. Ken Broda Bahm: Jury selection presents a difficult challenge to trial lawyers, and calls for skills that are generally out of step with the rest of what they’re expected to master in order to get from filing to verdict. At the point of empaneling a jury, lawyers are expected to listen more than

Know the Principles: A Review of the “Jury Selection Handbook” Read More »